PocketPriceFree iPhone app

Get the app
Reseller ToolkitNovember 17, 20268 min read

How to Tell Sterling Silver From Silver Plate: 6 Tests I Use (2026)

By Cody CockrumFull-time reseller since 2017 and owner of Room Swap Consignments in Holly Hill, SC.

Contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

Have one? Check what yours is worth, free

Almost every estate sale has a drawer of “silver.” Nearly all of it is plate, and the few sterling pieces in it are worth more than the rest put together. Here’s how I sort it, about a minute a piece.

This guide is about the tests. For what each mark means and what sterling and plate are worth, see our sterling silver vs. silver plate guide.

How to tell sterling from silver plate, step by step

1. Read the marks

Most pieces are marked, so this settles the majority of them. Look on the back of spoon and fork handles, under a bowl or tray, and near the foot of a candlestick, with a loupe and light from the side. Marks that mean solid silver:

  • Sterling, Sterling Silver, 925 or .925 (92.5% silver).
  • A walking lion among British hallmarks (sterling).
  • 800, 830 or 835 on European silver: lower than sterling, but still solid silver.
  • Coin or 900 on American silver from before about 1870.

Marks that mean plate:

  • EP, EPNS, EPBM or EPC (electroplated nickel silver, Britannia metal or copper).
  • Silverplate, Silver on Copper, Triple Plate, Quadruple Plate and A1.
  • Big brand names on their own: 1847 Rogers Bros., Wm. Rogers, Holmes & Edwards and Community are almost always plate. A famous name isn’t a sterling mark.

One more mark to know: “Weighted” on sterling candlesticks and some bowls means a thin sterling shell filled with plaster or resin. It’s sterling, but only a small part of the weight is silver.

2. Look at the wear

Silver plate is a thin coat over another metal, and it wears through first on the high points: the tips of fork tines, the back of a spoon bowl, the edges of a tray, the feet of a teapot. A coppery, brassy or yellowish metal showing through means plate. Sterling is silver all the way through, so a worn spot is just more silver.

3. Try a magnet

Silver isn’t magnetic. If a strong magnet grabs the piece, it’s plated steel or stainless, and you’re done. A small rare-earth magnet works best; I carry a strong magnet on a handle (opens in a new tab)a strong magnet on a handle so it doesn’t stick to everything else in my bag. A piece that ignores the magnet still isn’t proven: most plate is over brass, copper or nickel silver, which aren’t magnetic either. The magnet test guide goes deeper.

4. Use the ice test as a hint

Silver moves heat better than any other metal. Set an ice cube on a flat part of the piece, and on solid silver it starts to melt right away, as if the piece were warm. On plated nickel silver or brass it melts more slowly. Copper is fast too, so treat this as a hint that tells you which pieces to test properly, not as an answer.

5. Do the acid test

When the marks are worn or missing, acid decides. Wear gloves and glasses and work somewhere with air moving.

  1. Rub a hidden spot on a touchstone (the underside of a foot, the back of a handle tip) to leave a streak. On a piece you own, you can instead file a tiny notch in a hidden spot so you’re testing below any plating.
  2. Put one drop of silver testing solution on the streak or the notch.
  3. Read the color. Bright to deep red means silver: the deeper the red, the more like sterling. Brown, green or no red at all means plate, nickel silver or another base metal.
  4. Compare with a known piece. Streak a spoon you know is sterling next to it. If the known piece stops turning red, your solution has gone weak.
  5. Clean up with a damp paper towel and a pinch of baking soda.

Testing the surface without a scratch or a notch fools everyone: plated pieces have real silver on top, so they turn red too. Get below the plating.

6. Weigh what passes

Sterling’s floor is its weight. Multiply the grams by 0.925 and today’s silver price per gram to get melt value; the silver and metals price guide has a calculator with today’s spot price. Take weighted pieces and knife handles (filled with something other than silver) out of the melt math. A pocket scale that reads to 0.01 g does the job; see the best digital scale for resellers.

Don’t melt what sells for more

Many sterling flatware patterns sell for more as place settings than as scrap, and hollowware by good makers can bring several times its weight. Check the pattern before you sell anything by the ounce. Our sterling flatware value guide lists the patterns that sell best.

Silver marks from other countries

  • Britain: a walking lion (sterling), plus a town mark, a date letter and a maker’s initials.
  • Germany: 800 with a crescent moon and a crown, used from the late 1800s.
  • Mexico: Sterling or 925, often with a maker’s mark and, on older pieces, an eagle assay mark.
  • Russia: 84, the old Russian standard of about 87.5% silver.
  • Scandinavia and Europe: 830S, 835 and 800 are common, all solid silver below sterling.

Pieces people get wrong

  • Sterling-handled knives: the handle is a hollow sterling shell over cement, and the blade is stainless steel. Only a small part of the weight is silver.
  • Sterling on glass: pieces marked “Sterling” on a silver rim, base or overlay on glass are real silver, but only the silver part counts.
  • “Sheffield” on modern pieces: on newer trays and teapots, “Sheffield” or “Sheffield Silver Co.” is usually plate. Old Sheffield plate from the 1700s and early 1800s is silver fused to copper and collected on its own, but it isn’t sterling either.
  • Nickel silver and German silver: despite the names, they contain no silver at all.

Sorting a whole drawer of silver in ten minutes

  1. Lay it all out on a towel so nothing scratches.
  2. Read every piece with the loupe and make two piles: marked sterling and marked plate.
  3. Magnet the unmarked ones. Anything that sticks goes in the plate pile.
  4. Check the wear on what’s left. Brass or copper showing through goes to plate.
  5. Acid-test the few still in doubt, on the stone or a hidden notch.
  6. Sort the sterling by pattern before you weigh any of it, so you don’t melt a set that sells better whole.

Silver plate still sells

Plate has no melt value worth chasing, but it isn’t worthless. Ornate serving pieces, tea sets, trays with good decoration, and complete boxed sets sell well as table decor and for weddings, parties and holiday tables. Polish it, price it as decor and keep it moving. Plated flatware sells best in matched sets or as craft lots, since jewelry makers and crafters buy odd spoons and forks to bend into bracelets, wind chimes and garden markers.

Cleaning silver before you sell it

Light tarnish comes off with a soft silver cloth or a gentle silver polish and a soft cloth. Go easy on plate: heavy polishing wears through the thin silver to the metal underneath, which lowers its value. Never use the aluminum foil and baking soda dip on anything with a dark finish in its pattern, because it strips the dark detail that makes the design stand out. Leave old patina alone on pieces that collectors like dark, and wash off fingerprints after you polish, since they show up as tarnish later. Wrap clean silver in tissue or a silver bag so it stays bright in your booth case.

Silver testing tools: budget, what I use, and pro picks
Budget10x jeweler’s loupeBest for: Reading marks on flatware and hollowwareWhy: Most silver is marked. Reading the mark settles most pieces before you need anything else.See it on Amazon → (opens in a new tab)
What I useCody’s pickSilver testing solutionBest for: Unmarked or worn piecesWhy: One drop on a scratch: red means silver, anything else means plate or base metal.See it on Amazon → (opens in a new tab)
ProElectronic precious metal testerBest for: Testing a lot of silver and gold every weekWhy: Quick readings without acid or scratches. Check it against a known sterling piece.See it on Amazon → (opens in a new tab)

Mistakes to avoid

  • Calling “Quadruple Plate” or “1847 Rogers Bros.” sterling. Big names and big numbers, still plate.
  • Paying melt price for weighted candlesticks. Most of their weight is filler.
  • Testing the surface. Plate has real silver on top, so get below it with a streak or a hidden notch.
  • Judging by the polishing cloth. Plate turns a cloth black just like sterling does.
  • Selling a good flatware pattern by the ounce when it would bring more as place settings.

Check yours free

Try it right now — free, no account

Take a photo of one item and get a real price in seconds.

One free demo per visitor · Results in under 10 seconds

Quick answers

What does EPNS mean on silver?

Electroplated nickel silver: a thin coat of silver over nickel silver, an alloy of copper, nickel and zinc with no silver in it. EPNS pieces are silver plate, not sterling.

Is 800 silver the same as sterling?

No. 800 silver is 80 percent silver and sterling is 92.5 percent. Both are solid silver, and both are worth at least their silver content.

Does sterling silver stick to a magnet?

No. Silver is not magnetic. If a strong magnet grabs a piece, it is plated steel or stainless. But a piece that does not stick can still be plate over brass or nickel silver.

Is Rogers silverware sterling?

Almost always not. 1847 Rogers Bros., Wm. Rogers and most other Rogers marks are silver plate. A Rogers piece is sterling only if it is also marked Sterling or 925.

How much is sterling silver worth?

At least its melt value: weight in grams times 0.925 times the silver price per gram. Many flatware patterns and good hollowware sell for more than melt.