PocketPriceFree iPhone app

Get the app
TrendsNovember 16, 20267 min read

What Sells in January: A Reseller's After-Christmas Guide

By Cody CockrumFull-time reseller since 2017 and owner of Room Swap Consignments in Holly Hill, SC.

Have one? Check what yours is worth, free

What sells in January? For reselling, January is a reset month: shoppers are done buying gifts and start buying for themselves and their homes. Organization, fitness gear, winter clothing, Valentine's pieces and home office items move, and the good estates that waited until after the holidays start coming up for sale. Christmas stock, meanwhile, needs to go or go into storage. Here's what I stock, what I clear, where I source, and how I reset the booth for the new year.

What Sells in January

Typical local tags for good, clean pieces in an average market. January buyers are practical, so price to move.

CategoryWhy it sells nowTypical tag
Baskets, crates, bins, vintage tinsNew Year organizing$5–$35
Canisters, apothecary and Mason jarsPantry makeovers$5–$30
Dumbbells, kettlebells, exercise bikesResolutions$10–$150
Wool coats, flannel, bootsThe coldest weeks of the year$15–$85
Wool blankets and quiltsCold weather$20–$120
Valentine's cards, red glass, heart boxesShoppers start in mid-January$3–$40
Desks, file cabinets, desk lampsTax season and home offices$20–$200
Puzzles, board games, booksStaying in$2–$20
Dutch ovens, slow cookers, soup tureensComfort cooking$10–$90
Football and game-day barwarePlayoffs and the big game$5–$50

Organization and storage

This is the January category. Wire baskets, wooden crates, divided boxes, card-catalog drawers, tool caddies and tins all sell as storage. Merchandise them full: a crate holding rolled towels sells faster than an empty one. Group them by room: a kitchen shelf of canisters and jars, a closet corner of baskets and hat boxes, a desk with file boxes and pencil cups. Shoppers picture where it goes and buy two.

Fitness and outdoor

Weights, benches, bikes, yoga gear and hiking boots move in the first three weeks of the month. Clean them, test them and price them well under new, since shoppers are comparing against a sporting goods store. Put weights on the floor where people can pick them up. By February the resolution crowd thins out.

Winter gear

In most of the country January is the coldest month, and here in South Carolina it's when people finally buy a real coat. Wool and leather coats, Pendleton shirts, flannel and boots sell best when it's actually cold, so stock them heavy right after New Year's.

Valentine's

Put Valentine's out the first week of January. Vintage cards, red and pink glass, heart-shaped boxes, milk glass, costume jewelry and romantic decor sell steadily until about February 10. Red Fire-King, ruby glass and pink depression glass all look right in a red and white display.

Vintage Valentine cards from the 1930s through the 1960s sell best as a small framed group or a bundle of five, around $3 to $8 a card loose. Heart-shaped candy boxes, red glass candy dishes and sweetheart jewelry make good $10 to $25 gifts. Keep a few pieces under $10 near the front for kids buying for a teacher or a grandparent.

Tax season and home office

Small desks, filing cabinets, office chairs, bankers lamps and desk organizers sell to people setting up for tax season or working from home. Small desks under $100 go fast.

Post-holiday estate finds

Families often wait until after the holidays to settle a house, so January estate sales can be full of good, untouched contents. Those finds sell in January too: quality furniture, sterling, jewelry and mid-century pieces don't care what month it is.

Puzzles, games and comfort cooking

Cold, dark evenings send people looking for something to do at home. Complete jigsaw puzzles, vintage board games and paperbacks sell steadily, and so do Dutch ovens, slow cookers and big stockpots. Tape a note on puzzles that says whether you counted the pieces. It answers the first question every shopper has.

Price to Move in January

January foot traffic is lighter than December's, and shoppers have just looked at their credit card statements. They still buy, but they buy what they need, and they notice a fair price. A few rules I follow:

  • Keep most practical items under $25, where people buy without thinking it over.
  • Price storage pieces in sets: three baskets for $20 sells better than $8 each.
  • Don't discount good furniture just because it's January. Move it, restyle it, and give it a fresh tag only if it's been sitting.
  • Put the Valentine's pieces at full price. They have a deadline, and shoppers know it.

What to Clear Out

  • Ordinary Christmas stock: mark it 50% off the first week of January, 75% the second, then pull it. Don't let it take up shelf space through February.
  • Quality vintage Christmas: Shiny Brite, blow molds, ceramic trees and Department 56 hold value. Pull and store them for October instead of dumping them.
  • Fall and Thanksgiving leftovers: they're dead until September.
  • Boxed gift sets and anything that only made sense as a present.
  • Anything that's sat 90 days or more, holiday or not.

Our guide to when to mark down seasonal inventory has a full markdown schedule.

Where to Source in January

  • After-Christmas clearance. Big-box stores run 70% to 90% off holiday decor, gift sets and wrap in the first two weeks of January. Buy only what stores well and sells next fall, and keep receipts for your cost of goods.
  • January estate sales. Fewer shoppers brave the cold, so day-two and day-three deals are better than any other time of year. See shopping estate sales in winter.
  • Thrift stores after the holidays. Donations spike in late December and early January as people make room for new gifts and finish year-end giving.
  • Facebook Marketplace declutterers. New Year purge posts are full of furniture and boxed lots priced to be gone by the weekend.
  • Indoor flea markets. Winter flea vendors want to lighten up before spring. See indoor flea markets in winter.

The Q4 buys that didn't sell feed into this too. Our Q4 holiday sourcing guide covers what to buy for next season while it's cheap.

A January Plan, Week by Week

  1. Week 1: clear Christmas at 50% off, pack the good vintage for storage, and hit after-Christmas clearance. Put organizing, fitness and Valentine's out.
  2. Week 2: reset the booth, re-check old tags, and shop the first January estate sales.
  3. Week 3: fill holes with winter clothing and home office pieces while it's cold, and pull any Christmas still left.
  4. Week 4: add more Valentine's, then start looking ahead: Easter, spring cleaning and the first garden pieces come next.

Booth Reset Tips for the New Year

  1. Empty it and deep clean. Dust shelves, wipe glass, fix lights. A bright, clean booth sells more in a slow month.
  2. Move the furniture. Regulars have seen your December layout. Swap the big pieces so the booth looks new from the aisle.
  3. Pick a January color story: white, wood and neutrals for organizing, with one red and pink corner for Valentine's.
  4. Put organizing and storage up front, where shoppers see it first.
  5. Re-check every tag older than 90 days. Lower it, bundle it or pull it.
  6. Count your inventory for taxes while the booth is apart. See year-end inventory count.

PocketPrice helps with the reset: price your new finds for your area from a photo, see which items have been sitting longest, and print fresh tags. The booth tools are on PocketPrice for booth vendors.

Check yours free

Try it right now — free, no account

Take a photo of one item and get a real price in seconds.

One free demo per visitor · Results in under 10 seconds

Quick answers

What sells best for resellers in January?

Organization and storage pieces, fitness equipment, winter coats and blankets, Valentine’s decor, desks and home office items, puzzles and games, and comfort cookware like Dutch ovens.

Should I keep Christmas items in my booth in January?

Mark ordinary Christmas stock down hard in the first week or two of January, then pull it. Store quality vintage Christmas pieces such as Shiny Brite ornaments and blow molds for next fall instead of dumping them.

When should I put out Valentine’s Day items?

The first week of January. Valentine’s pieces sell steadily from early January until about February 10.

Is January a good month to source inventory?

Yes. After-Christmas clearance runs 70% to 90% off, thrift stores fill with holiday donations, and January estate sales have fewer shoppers, so later-day discounts go further.

Stop guessing. Start pricing in seconds.

Snap a photo, get your price — calibrated to your venue, your region, and how you sell.

Try PocketPrice Free